DL Seminar | Untangling the Loop –Four Legal Approaches to Human Oversight
- Digital Life Initiative
- Apr 18, 2024
- 2 min read

Reflection by Ka Wing Lui (scroll below).
By Ka Wing Lui
Cornell Tech
In today’s seminar, Professor Jake Goldenfein gave us a talk titled Untangling the Loop –
Four Legal Approaches to Human Oversight. Professor Jake Goldenfein is a senior lecturer at Melbourne Law School and has been a researcher at Cornell Tech, Cornell University. In the seminar, he discussed about four legal forms of human oversight for AI and automation.
Professor Goldenfein started with talking about two typical diagnoses of why human oversight fails, one diagnosis is that the model of the human is wrong, that more time and training are needed to make decisions, and more specifically, means to look to human factors for empirical truth of the human. Another diagnosis is that the law is too vague, and needs to provide more principles as scaffolding, and more specifically Sui generis laws for each technical application.
Professor Goldenfein then discussed about several related paradigms and how they
evolved overtime. Firstly, humans as a moral agent that make “accountable decisions”, which
entails that these decisions can only be made by humans. Then, human as a flawed operator for “distribution of responsibility”. Human computation capacity cannot be quantified. Not only dealing with human and machine, but always need to consider organizational context. Professor Goldenfein used deadly crash accident with self-driving Uber as an example. The next paradigm Professor Goldenfein mentioned is human as a safety feature with “product liability”. Now, human oversight became to serve as a service. For example, human loop to be purchased for AWS, which is to build and refine AI models with humans in the loop workflow. The last paradigm is that humans as rights attractors and creative labor, for example, the discussion that for a writing piece, is that only the portion written by humans can have copyright.
Overall, Professor Goldenfein's seminar serves as a compelling lens through which to examine the multifaceted interplay between human agency, technological advancements, and legal frameworks within the expansive landscape of digital life. By navigating these complex intersections, the discourse not only enriches our understanding of contemporary challenges but also paves the way for informed and ethical engagement with emerging technologies.
Fascinating discussion on human oversight in tech! For teams working on AI and legal-tech projects, using free project management software can help structure tasks, responsibilities, and compliance checkpoints effectively.
Pest Control Near Me – Spiroach Pestcontrol
Looking for reliable pest control near me? Spiroach Pestcontrol has you covered with fast, safe, and effective solutions for all types of pest infestations. Whether it’s cockroaches in the kitchen, ants in the garden, termites damaging your structure, or rodents nesting in your attic, our experienced team knows how to handle it all.
We pride ourselves on using eco-friendly treatments that are tough on pests but safe for your family, pets, and the environment. Our licensed professionals arrive promptly, assess the issue thoroughly, and provide targeted treatments that work. With Spiroach Pestcontrol, you’ll receive customised pest control plans tailored to your home or business needs.
As a locally trusted provider, we understand the…
Fascinating insights on human oversight in AI! As tech evolves, even tools like free project management software must consider ethical frameworks and accountability in design.
Window Film NZ – Wrapcity
At Wrapcity, we’re redefining comfort, style, and privacy with our premium window film solutions in New Zealand. Whether you're looking to reduce glare, enhance security, protect your interiors from harmful UV rays, or simply elevate the look of your space, our expertly installed window films are a perfect choice. Our films are designed to offer long-lasting performance while adding aesthetic appeal to both residential and commercial properties.
Wrapcity specialises in a wide range of window films, including solar control, privacy, decorative, and safety films. With energy efficiency becoming more important than ever, our window films help regulate indoor temperatures, reducing reliance on air conditioning and ultimately lowering energy costs. From sleek, modern tints to frosted…
The Air France Office in Abuja serves as a local hub for customer support, flight bookings, and travel assistance for Air France passengers. Conveniently located in Nigeria's capital, the office offers services such as ticket reservations, itinerary changes, baggage inquiries, and general travel information. Whether you're planning a trip to France or any global destination, the Air France Office in Abuja is your trusted point of contact for all travel-related needs.